Veterans who face a tough training camp challenge

Started by bwiser, May 09, 2023, 11:38:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

bwiser

Who do you think are the veterans most in danger of losing their jobs? I think most of the positions are pretty safe particularly on offense. I think Liegghio and Winston Rose are in the most jeopardy. There are 24 Db's in camp so the Bombers are still looking to improve in the secondary. The other veteran who could be in some trouble is Kyrie Wilson if he hasn't recovered fully from a serious achilles injury.

pjrocksmb

Leggs and Rose make it.  Wilson depends on health but he is very good.  Just my 2 cents.

kkc60

it?s always interesting to kind of brainstorm names that could be at risk. of course injuries factor in, but it?s difficult to see really any surprise cuts. Leggs, Rose and Wilson are probably the three most realistic. Maybe Ricky Walker counts too? Although we really brought very little defensive tackle competition (outside of the canadian 4 + Adamson). Not too sure if Lawrence, Holm, Parker or Houston would qualify as surprises. All flashed but it?s a numbers game.

Blue In BC

We always bring in a ton of DB's so I wouldn't read too much into that. You need to have 2 or 3 on the PR and injuries in TC could move the depth chart upwards.

2022 injuries to Wilson and Houston could be roster issues both short and long term. If healthy, all is good. We don't know what their actual status is at the moment. I doubt Rose is at risk but maybe we find the next Alford, and DB careers are short.

I'd bet Leigghio is on the game day one roster. Obviously some fans want him cut already. We'll see how it goes.

Because of age and some new depth, I still wonder about Briggs whose performance slipped in 2022. Benson is another whose age could work against him. Both can still add value but it's not impossible a rookie Canadian is too good to allow to slip through the cracks.

Clements and Cole don't exactly have defined roles and rookies and or ratio decisions may push them off the roster. A rookie is more likely to be willing to sit on the PR.

McCrae: I like him but barring injury he won't be the starter or a DI. Tough call because I think he adds value if you can get him on the roster. How does he fit.

Agudosi: Similar to McCrae. How do you get him on the roster? Injury recovery status not known and I don't know if he's willing to sit on PR again.

Bombers could roster a couple of these players on the 1 game IR while seeing how newbies do. At some point a decision has to be made.

Some hard calls but roster size is limited, SMS is always an issue. 



Take no prisoners

TecnoGenius

Losing their jobs in TC, or during the season?

It seems clear WFC gives players their "injury mulligan" but if they have another big one we let them walk.  So that puts Wilson on the bubble.  He'll have to have a good year and stay pretty healthy.

I think Rose bounces back.  I'm not worried about him.  He was getting beat mentally, and was too aggressive.  He'll learn from that.  You need a couple of good vets in the DB field, especially with a lot of relatively young faces.

Really as for 3+ year WFC or 5+ year CFL vets there's really no starting IMP other than Wilson with a shot of getting cut out of TC, or really at all in-season.  The DIs and PRs on the other hand, especially recent acquisitions from other teams, always are at risk.  Lawrence and Darby are in that position.  Especially Lawrence.

I won't delve too much into vet NATs.  They kind of follow different rules and progressions.

Stable roster usually == success in the CFL.  That's a good thing.
Never go full Rider!

DM83

We usually injured list the non- starters, if they will play at some point.

Sec223

I'm thinking this is the last year for a few vets. Father Time is knocking on the door. Fingers crossed no one ends their career with an injury.

NewBlue

Quote from: Sec223 on May 10, 2023, 11:55:58 AM
I'm thinking this is the last year for a few vets. Father Time is knocking on the door. Fingers crossed no one ends their career with an injury.

Agree on all points.  Part of the process needs to be to find the young guys that can just soak up the game this year, and get more playing time next year.
Would love to see Bighill stick around with the club in a coaching position next year.

Sir Blue and Gold

Veterans (or at least players who played last year) who need to have good camps or could be in trouble of outright release (might be bubble players depending how they show up to camp):
Kyrie Wilson
Marc Legghio
Winston Rose
Carlton Agudosi
Evan Holm

Veterans (or at least players who played last year) who have serious competition for their starting spot:
Chris Kolankowski
Pat Neufeld
Rasheed Bailey
Jackson Jeffcoat

Buck


KINGCHARLES

Quote from: Sir Blue and Gold on May 10, 2023, 01:18:00 PM
Veterans (or at least players who played last year) who need to have good camps or could be in trouble of outright release (might be bubble players depending how they show up to camp):
Kyrie Wilson
Marc Legghio
Winston Rose
Carlton Agudosi
Evan Holm

Veterans (or at least players who played last year) who have serious competition for their starting spot:
Chris Kolankowski
Pat Neufeld
Rasheed Bailey

Jackson Jeffcoat

I personally hope that Rose just had an "off" year, he struggled a bit with a foot/lower body injury  for the first 5-7 weeks of the season, and there was also a lot of moving pieces on defence last year due to injuries that affect the whole defensive style.
Neufeld....wasnt he a CFL all-star, yes Dobson might be able to play all interior positions but im not sure if you just swoop in and steal Neufelds spot.
Bailey, he took a massive pay cut compared to rumoured offers from other teams, i think the Bombers keep him no matter what. He's probably the best downfield blocking WR in the entire CFL and also arguably the best run blocking WR in the CFL, sometimes you can't teach/coach that ability.

Jeffcoat is an amazing compliment to Jefferson when healthy, he equally helps the entire healthy defence elevate their game. We need someone that can fill in and provide the same level play or better for when the Jeffs need rest or if Jeffcoat gets injured. Makes me think if someone was to have an amazing TC/preseason, Jeffcoat could be expendable (and i don't like the thought of him not being a Bomber)
BEASTS OF THE EAST

I DON'T BRAKE FOR RIDER FANS

Sir Blue and Gold

#11
Quote from: KINGCHARLES on May 10, 2023, 04:02:44 PM
I personally hope that Rose just had an "off" year, he struggled a bit with a foot/lower body injury  for the first 5-7 weeks of the season, and there was also a lot of moving pieces on defence last year due to injuries that affect the whole defensive style.
Neufeld....wasnt he a CFL all-star, yes Dobson might be able to play all interior positions but im not sure if you just swoop in and steal Neufelds spot.
Bailey, he took a massive pay cut compared to rumoured offers from other teams, i think the Bombers keep him no matter what. He's probably the best downfield blocking WR in the entire CFL and also arguably the best run blocking WR in the CFL, sometimes you can't teach/coach that ability.

Jeffcoat is an amazing compliment to Jefferson when healthy, he equally helps the entire healthy defence elevate their game. We need someone that can fill in and provide the same level play or better for when the Jeffs need rest or if Jeffcoat gets injured. Makes me think if someone was to have an amazing TC/preseason, Jeffcoat could be expendable (and i don't like the thought of him not being a Bomber)

Totally agree on all counts. Probably all those vets are safe, like you say, but I can envision some 'what if scenarios' that are possible, such as:

- Rose comes in and has regressed further. Having already lost the boundary corner spot last year, he's an expensive field corner that could be beat out by younger/cheaper/faster. It's a relatively comfortable spot to play for a lot of new Americans.
- Dobson comes in big, strong and ready. Neufeld transitions to the best in-game emergency OL in the league (although the fact he can't play centre is problematic).
- Jeffcoat gets hurt in training camp (which would be unsurprising) and one of the young Americans shows promise. He starts the year on the one game IR and his younger, cheaper replacement delivers in the first few weeks of the season.
- Bailey, while a fantastic blocker, is beat out by a fantastic young American who is a much better overall receiver, cheaper, with tons of upside. Bailey starts the year on the 1 game IR and enters limbo land. Although the Bombers appreciate his team-friendly deal, there was a reason he was asked to sign it in the first place which is the truest indicator of the organization's perceived value of the player.

the paw

Quote from: Sir Blue and Gold on May 10, 2023, 04:17:44 PM
Totally agree on all counts. Probably all those vets are safe, like you say, but I can envision some 'what if scenarios' that are possible, such as:

- Rose comes in and has regressed further. Having already lost the boundary corner spot last year, he's an expensive field corner that could be beat out by younger/cheaper/faster. It's a relatively comfortable spot to play for a lot of new Americans.
- Dobson comes in big, strong and ready. Neufeld transitions to the best in-game emergency OL in the league (although the fact he can't play centre is problematic).
- Jeffcoat gets hurt in training camp (which would be unsurprising) and one of the young Americans shows promise. He starts the year on the one game IR and his younger, cheaper replacement delivers in the first few weeks of the season.
- Bailey, while a fantastic blocker, is beat out by a fantastic young American who is a much better overall receiver, cheaper, with tons of upside. Bailey starts the year on the 1 game IR and enters limbo land. Although the Bombers appreciate his team-friendly deal, there was a reason he was asked to sign it in the first place which is the truest indicator of the organization's perceived value of the player.


I think Dobson will eventually get Neufeld's spot, but I don't think its this year.  If he does, Neufeld will retire, I don't think he will be a sixth man.

Even if Jeffcoat gets hurt in camp, they probably carry him for the year.  Although that might be the writing on the wall. 

If anyone on planet Earth had any faith in Agudosi's durability, I don't think Bailey would have been re-signed.  I don't know how they are managing to pay all these receivers, but it seems pretty clear that once Schoen is off his rookie deal, it is hard to imagine a budget that retains him, Demski and Lawler.  So they have to be looking at all these new guys with an eye to next year.  And since they are looking, I agree that Bailey might not have a lot of wiggle room. 
grab grass 'n growl

Blue In BC

Quote from: the paw on May 10, 2023, 05:00:42 PM
I think Dobson will eventually get Neufeld's spot, but I don't think its this year.  If he does, Neufeld will retire, I don't think he will be a sixth man.

Even if Jeffcoat gets hurt in camp, they probably carry him for the year.  Although that might be the writing on the wall. 

If anyone on planet Earth had any faith in Agudosi's durability, I don't think Bailey would have been re-signed.  I don't know how they are managing to pay all these receivers, but it seems pretty clear that once Schoen is off his rookie deal, it is hard to imagine a budget that retains him, Demski and Lawler.  So they have to be looking at all these new guys with an eye to next year.  And since they are looking, I agree that Bailey might not have a lot of wiggle room. 

Agudosi will initially be headed to the PR IMO. I don't see him beating out Bailey to start the season. As the season progresses, an injury or performance issue may change that. However, we may have some new contenders among the rookies. Injury history is certainly a possible issue.

Next year is next year. Sure we expect that SMS may come more into play with all the veterans we have. OTOH we could see some significant retirements on the OL and resulting SMS changes.

Take no prisoners

Sir Blue and Gold

#14
Quote from: the paw on May 10, 2023, 05:00:42 PM
I think Dobson will eventually get Neufeld's spot, but I don't think its this year.  If he does, Neufeld will retire, I don't think he will be a sixth man.

Even if Jeffcoat gets hurt in camp, they probably carry him for the year.  Although that might be the writing on the wall. 

If anyone on planet Earth had any faith in Agudosi's durability, I don't think Bailey would have been re-signed.  I don't know how they are managing to pay all these receivers, but it seems pretty clear that once Schoen is off his rookie deal, it is hard to imagine a budget that retains him, Demski and Lawler.  So they have to be looking at all these new guys with an eye to next year.  And since they are looking, I agree that Bailey might not have a lot of wiggle room. 

True - however keep in mind the salary cap increased $160,000 this off-season and will go up another $75,000 next season, followed by $100,000 increases in year 2025, 2026, and 2027. Players will also receive 25% of revenue (via the revenue sharing agreement) starting in 2024, and the CFL can reimburse how it sees fit, which possibly can be added to the cap. So if it felt like GMs were throwing a little more money around this off-season, they were (about $1.4M more). Assuming those with highest leverage take a disproportionate amount of the increases, then that money likely goes to QBs, star Americans (Lawler/Shoen) and actually good Canadians (Demski).