Front Office Salary Cap

Started by theaardvark, Today at 03:24:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

theaardvark

We've heard that the player cap is increasing, but no word on if or how much the coaching cap is changing.

It may be time to get rid of it completely, it never made sense to me, if a team wants to go into red ink because it needs a change at the top to be competitive, they should be allowed to.

You can cut players with no hit to the cap, while there may be signing bonuses and some guaranteed money, most of their contracts are not guaranteed.

Coaches deals are usually multi-year and 100% guaranteed.

You can't change the whole team, but you can change the whole direction of a team by removing part or all of the coaching staff.

I know the intent was to prevent teams from luring away successful coaches with huge deals, so they put the same provisions in that prevented that from happening with players.  But they left out the fact that the contracts each signs are completely different, and a cap can hurt a struggling team badly.

Raise the cap considerably, remove it altogether, or make it a "current staff" cap, allowing teams to negotiate releases of coaches with no cap hit.  Let them pay out contracts outside the cap, as long as the coach no longer "works" for them.

The front office cap should never have been equivalent to the player cap.  And one mulligan is not significant for a team that is rebuilding.  It can take a few tries to land on the proper management team.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.

Jesse

I know fans hate it, but from the CFL's perspective, the coaches cap is a gigantic success. The intent has nothing to do with luring away coaches, it's to keep costs down to lure in ownership groups. We had BC, Edmonton, and Montreal on sale several times each over a very short period. Organizational costs were too high and it was difficult to find ownership.

Even with stableish owners now, the league is still trying to expand. Do not expect the cap to go anywhere.
My wife is amazing!

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Jesse on Today at 04:14:31 PMI know fans hate it, but from the CFL's perspective, the coaches cap is a gigantic success. The intent has nothing to do with luring away coaches, it's to keep costs down to lure in ownership groups. We had BC, Edmonton, and Montreal on sale several times each over a very short period. Organizational costs were too high and it was difficult to find ownership.

Even with stableish owners now, the league is still trying to expand. Do not expect the cap to go anywhere.

Still, if there is extra revenue going to the players a proportion should go to the coaches.  That could be in the form of adding an extra position or two or increasing the pay for those on the lower rungs of the coaching ladder.  I think the ones at the top are paid well enough.

theaardvark

Quote from: Jesse on Today at 04:14:31 PMI know fans hate it, but from the CFL's perspective, the coaches cap is a gigantic success. The intent has nothing to do with luring away coaches, it's to keep costs down to lure in ownership groups. We had BC, Edmonton, and Montreal on sale several times each over a very short period. Organizational costs were too high and it was difficult to find ownership.

Even with stableish owners now, the league is still trying to expand. Do not expect the cap to go anywhere.

Not sure why the present cap would be preferred by owners to a "current staff" cap.

Getting stuck with a staff that is underperforming is worse that getting stuvk with players that are underperforming, a one year difference in players is huge due to FA, but not being able to hire new coaches/managers because a multi year deal is preventing you from making a change DEVALUES a franchise, and the damage can take years to recover from.

A cap makes sense, yes.  But the current cap does not, IMHO.  You can acheive the same cost certainty that makes a franchise more appealing with a current staff cap, while allowing a franchise to escape a bad management team and rebuild with only a monetary consequence, which could be made up rapidly with the increased gate a better team brings in.

Just makes sense.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.