Mike O’Shea Fired

Started by Jesse, November 19, 2026, 12:36:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

bunker

Quote from: bluengold204 on November 19, 2026, 09:09:53 PMTo me our problems for the last few years stem from the o-line unable to protect and give our QBs time.  Would Rourke get us a few more wins ?  Maybe but I'm not all that sold on it.

We have seen in the last few years that the elite QBs often don't win you the grey cup, the notion you need one to win is kind of a myth
No question our O-line was a big part of the problem. And there's a limit to what even an elite QB can do with a terrible O-line (see Michael Riley in Edmonton). But IMO its even more important to have the right QB when the O-line is not great. You need a QB who is mobile, and can either extend plays, or turn something into nothing with a scramble for positive yards. If you watch Rourke, Alexander or even Fajardo this year, they were constantly doing this. Zach occasionally would turn back the clock, but for the most part, he could not.

As for the Grey Cup and elite QBs, yes... Arbuckle yada yada yada. But is you look at the winning QBs in the last 20 years most of them were elite. And some that are not generally seen as elite, like Fajardo, put on elite perfomances in crucial games. Its not a guarantee, but elite QB play give you a huge advantage in pursuing a cup, and thats why teams are willing to break the bank to aquire and keep them.


markf

#91
The team Needs a coach that can help Brown, Perkins, Elgersma.


Probably that's Calvillo.

I don't think they'll dick around like they did when Buck left.  bringing in Jarious Jackson to do who knows what.

Some funny goings on.

My. Least favourite moment is Grey Cup, when they put Dakota Prukop in , in the red zone with mvp on the sidelines.

Highlight was underdog grey cup win over the Ticats

dd

Quote from: bunker on November 19, 2026, 09:46:11 PMNo question our O-line was a big part of the problem. And there's a limit to what even an elite QB can do with a terrible O-line (see Michael Riley in Edmonton). But IMO its even more important to have the right QB when the O-line is not great. You need a QB who is mobile, and can either extend plays, or turn something into nothing with a scramble for positive yards. If you watch Rourke, Alexander or even Fajardo this year, they were constantly doing this. Zach occasionally would turn back the clock, but for the most part, he could not.

As for the Grey Cup and elite QBs, yes... Arbuckle yada yada yada. But is you look at the winning QBs in the last 20 years most of them were elite. And some that are not generally seen as elite, like Fajardo, put on elite perfomances in crucial games. Its not a guarantee, but elite QB play give you a huge advantage in pursuing a cup, and thats why teams are willing to break the bank to aquire and keep them.


You're right. We had the leagues worst O line and by far the most immobile Qb in the league, and with that, you get a struggling offense. If he was insisting we keep and start aging vets like Bryant and Collaros, that could be why we are parting ways. 

Pitbull

With Wade Miller announcing O'Shea's departure, is that normal?

I would have thought Walters would have announced that. Unless, Walters is also departing?

I've been concerned with the Blue Bombers drafting as we haven't paid a lot of attention to OL's which is the anchor of any good CFL team.

ModAdmin

My uneducated guess is that there will be several departures by coaches, players and others with the decision to let Mike O'Shea go.

Some might include Bryant, Neufeld, Collaros, Jefferson and other coaches unless one of them is promoted to head coach (unlikely IMHO).
"You can't let praise or criticism get to you. It's a weakness to get caught up in either one." - John Wooden

BlueInCgy

With Harris announcing he's not staying in Regina, guessing he wants a shot at one of the coaching positions. 

dd

If we're going to go in a 'different direction', to me, that rules out promoting anyone from within. Miller wants a different, strong leader, who will bring in new ideas and objective perspective on who to re-sign and who to move on from. Coaches from within will have the same ties to the old vets, so they aren't going to let them go , and that's the problem I can see, a different direction means going away from the old guard, and that included MOS.

VictorRomano

Quote from: BlueInCgy on Today at 12:44:53 AMWith Harris announcing he's not staying in Regina, guessing he wants a shot at one of the coaching positions. 

Jovon Johnson announced he's leaving the Argos as secondary coach, too.

Tecno

This hit me like I'm 16 and my girlfriend just dumped me.  Not a fun thing to wake up to.

This is about as life-altering vis a vis the Bombers as you can get.  I would argue this is more life altering than if WM was fired -- or even KW.  The HC sets the tone for everything, including personnel, coords, coaches, direction.  Everything.

What this means is everything is on the table and probably nothing will be the same.  Welcome to 2014.  Don't forget how many years it took to get "good" then...

My hunch is WM/KW already have an idea of 1-2 guys that are very likely to take the job.  If a Prez were to fire an HC who was one Demski block away from a GC appearance, and then not have any good candidates and then install a Hogan as HC, lose quality players left & right as they follow the old HC out, and win 4 games next year, then that Prez would be looking at getting fired himself.  Therefore it is guaranteed they already have the guy lined up, or they have a short list of great candidates that they know for sure will yield one signed HC.

The only other alternative was MOS was 100% going to OTT, and doing this "firing" now is advantageous to both teams.  It would then make WM/KW look like they were in control, vs OTT being in control.

I would not overlook Condell becoming HC+OC.  He's been on the fast-track, and WFC is eyeing getting more "energetic".  There's no one more energetic than Condell.
Never go full Johnston!

Tecno

Quote from: ModAdmin on Today at 12:41:16 AMMy uneducated guess is that there will be several departures by coaches, players and others with the decision to let Mike O'Shea go.

There will be a ton that follow MOS to OTT.  MOS lifers -- like Kramdi.  As well as the less coaches/coords.

I don't think anyone on the team really HATES MOS and will stay just to stick it to him.  But I do know for sure there are a ton of MOS loyalists that will follow him if they ask -- and do it at a discount.

The upshot is we won't get the MOS-lifer discount from basically anyone, and we WILL be paying more to draw new talent to an unproven/fresh team.
Never go full Johnston!

Tecno

Quote from: Sir Blue and Gold on November 19, 2026, 09:22:52 PMNot only is the above true, but also not leveraging the roster rules after so many seasons was a red flag. So was his coordinator choice and his refusal to be more aggressive across the board chasing wins. Did we run a fake all year?

Well, "winning" the 25-snap rule will net the new HC a free 2RDP.  Which is important considering we're out at minimum our 1RDP this season.  The new guy, who may not get get that 2RDP in '28 because he'll use the 25-snap rule, will benefit without any of the pain.

Hey, what if it was MOS who pushed hard for the failed Dru Brown 1RDP giveaway, and this is the punishment?  It may be one of the dumbest trades in CFL history... especially if Dru just walks in FA.
Never go full Johnston!

Tecno

Quote from: Pete on November 19, 2026, 09:15:03 PMOver the last three years our team has regressed, as we aged our w/l record deteriorated. Something significant had to change, and if OShea wasn't willing to make the changes then Miller did the right thing.

Everyone is forgetting that KW is in the middle.  For hiring new players, KW is the ultimate boss.  MOS can provide input, but nothing can be done if KW doesn't agree.  If it's personnel issues and MOS gets fired but KW doesn't, then that would mean there was a rift between KW & MOS.
Never go full Johnston!

Tecno

Quote from: bluengold204 on November 19, 2026, 09:09:53 PMWe have seen in the last few years that the elite QBs often don't win you the grey cup, the notion you need one to win is kind of a myth

Very true.  It's usually the older/experienced QBs that win you the cup.  It's the young bucks that win you reg season games and look great, and then blow it in the post-season -- until they too become old/experienced.

26 Cody (11 years)
25 Trevor (13 years)
24 Nick (7 years)
23 Cody (8 years)
22 MBT (5 years)
21 Zach (9 years)
19 Zach (7 years)
18 BLM (6 years)
17 ray (15 years)

With MBT being an outlier, you need 6-8 years to be cup-winning material, and 9, 11, 13, 15 aren't abnormal.

Alexander, Rourke & Kelly are the young studs who look great, but need more seasoning before they can do it.  That said, winning tons of games at home probably drives STH sales more than cup wins.  As long as you do "ok" in the playoffs, that's usually good enough.
Never go full Johnston!

Tecno

Quote from: Waffler on November 19, 2026, 08:49:49 PMMOS said a bunch of times that Zach is the best QB in the league
THIS is the problem. He's the only one that thinks that. The roster suffered.

What MOS says to the press has nothing to do with what he's thinking.  He'll never bad mouth anyone on the team.  Anyone.  He hasn't the entire time he's been here.

MOS could very easily say today Zach is the best QB, and then tomorrow announce they are moving on.  And this would be 100% consistent with the MOS philosophy.
Never go full Johnston!

Jesse

Quote from: VictorRomano on Today at 01:21:44 AMJovon Johnson announced he's leaving the Argos as secondary coach, too.

Buck is assembling his squad, lol.
My wife is amazing!