Front Office Salary Cap

Started by theaardvark, November 16, 2026, 03:24:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

theaardvark

We've heard that the player cap is increasing, but no word on if or how much the coaching cap is changing.

It may be time to get rid of it completely, it never made sense to me, if a team wants to go into red ink because it needs a change at the top to be competitive, they should be allowed to.

You can cut players with no hit to the cap, while there may be signing bonuses and some guaranteed money, most of their contracts are not guaranteed.

Coaches deals are usually multi-year and 100% guaranteed.

You can't change the whole team, but you can change the whole direction of a team by removing part or all of the coaching staff.

I know the intent was to prevent teams from luring away successful coaches with huge deals, so they put the same provisions in that prevented that from happening with players.  But they left out the fact that the contracts each signs are completely different, and a cap can hurt a struggling team badly.

Raise the cap considerably, remove it altogether, or make it a "current staff" cap, allowing teams to negotiate releases of coaches with no cap hit.  Let them pay out contracts outside the cap, as long as the coach no longer "works" for them.

The front office cap should never have been equivalent to the player cap.  And one mulligan is not significant for a team that is rebuilding.  It can take a few tries to land on the proper management team.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.

Jesse

I know fans hate it, but from the CFL's perspective, the coaches cap is a gigantic success. The intent has nothing to do with luring away coaches, it's to keep costs down to lure in ownership groups. We had BC, Edmonton, and Montreal on sale several times each over a very short period. Organizational costs were too high and it was difficult to find ownership.

Even with stableish owners now, the league is still trying to expand. Do not expect the cap to go anywhere.
My wife is amazing!

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Jesse on November 16, 2026, 04:14:31 PMI know fans hate it, but from the CFL's perspective, the coaches cap is a gigantic success. The intent has nothing to do with luring away coaches, it's to keep costs down to lure in ownership groups. We had BC, Edmonton, and Montreal on sale several times each over a very short period. Organizational costs were too high and it was difficult to find ownership.

Even with stableish owners now, the league is still trying to expand. Do not expect the cap to go anywhere.

Still, if there is extra revenue going to the players a proportion should go to the coaches.  That could be in the form of adding an extra position or two or increasing the pay for those on the lower rungs of the coaching ladder.  I think the ones at the top are paid well enough.

theaardvark

Quote from: Jesse on November 16, 2026, 04:14:31 PMI know fans hate it, but from the CFL's perspective, the coaches cap is a gigantic success. The intent has nothing to do with luring away coaches, it's to keep costs down to lure in ownership groups. We had BC, Edmonton, and Montreal on sale several times each over a very short period. Organizational costs were too high and it was difficult to find ownership.

Even with stableish owners now, the league is still trying to expand. Do not expect the cap to go anywhere.

Not sure why the present cap would be preferred by owners to a "current staff" cap.

Getting stuck with a staff that is underperforming is worse that getting stuvk with players that are underperforming, a one year difference in players is huge due to FA, but not being able to hire new coaches/managers because a multi year deal is preventing you from making a change DEVALUES a franchise, and the damage can take years to recover from.

A cap makes sense, yes.  But the current cap does not, IMHO.  You can acheive the same cost certainty that makes a franchise more appealing with a current staff cap, while allowing a franchise to escape a bad management team and rebuild with only a monetary consequence, which could be made up rapidly with the increased gate a better team brings in.

Just makes sense.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.

Jesse

Quote from: theaardvark on November 16, 2026, 07:07:42 PMNot sure why the present cap would be preferred by owners to a "current staff" cap.

Getting stuck with a staff that is underperforming is worse that getting stuvk with players that are underperforming, a one year difference in players is huge due to FA, but not being able to hire new coaches/managers because a multi year deal is preventing you from making a change DEVALUES a franchise, and the damage can take years to recover from.

A cap makes sense, yes.  But the current cap does not, IMHO.  You can acheive the same cost certainty that makes a franchise more appealing with a current staff cap, while allowing a franchise to escape a bad management team and rebuild with only a monetary consequence, which could be made up rapidly with the increased gate a better team brings in.

Just makes sense.

The monetary consequence is literally what the cap is trying to avoid. Thats why it exists.
My wife is amazing!

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Jesse on November 16, 2026, 10:34:20 PMThe monetary consequence is literally what the cap is trying to avoid. Thats why it exists.

Now the CFLPA is talking about fully guaranteed contracts, I don't know if this is supposed to be for specific players or for all, but it seems like a dangerous financial path to explore.

The Canadian Football League Players' Association (CFLPA) planted its flag on a key issue during Grey Cup week in Calgary: fully guaranteed contracts.

In their press conference on Friday, executive director David Mackie and president Solomon Elimimian indicated they want members to be eligible to sign fully guaranteed contracts, something that has never been previously available to CFL players.

"Guaranteed contracts would help provide greater stability for our members, while helping build roster continuity," said Mackie. "We want to see more of these guaranteed contracts, which will lead to more engagement with the community, build relationships with fans, fewer blank jerseys on game day, and become part of the cities and provinces that they represent."

https://3downnation.com/2026/11/13/cflpa-wants-fully-guaranteed-contracts/

Jesse

Quote from: Throw Long Bannatyne on November 16, 2026, 11:26:24 PMNow the CFLPA is talking about fully guaranteed contracts, I don't know if this is supposed to be for specific players or for all, but it seems like a dangerous financial path to explore.

The Canadian Football League Players' Association (CFLPA) planted its flag on a key issue during Grey Cup week in Calgary: fully guaranteed contracts.

In their press conference on Friday, executive director David Mackie and president Solomon Elimimian indicated they want members to be eligible to sign fully guaranteed contracts, something that has never been previously available to CFL players.

"Guaranteed contracts would help provide greater stability for our members, while helping build roster continuity," said Mackie. "We want to see more of these guaranteed contracts, which will lead to more engagement with the community, build relationships with fans, fewer blank jerseys on game day, and become part of the cities and provinces that they represent."

https://3downnation.com/2026/11/13/cflpa-wants-fully-guaranteed-contracts/

They want it something that can be bargained for, it's not like all contracts would be guaranteed.

No reason they should be unable to sign guarantees if the teams are willing to do it.
My wife is amazing!

Tecno

Think of the cap from a WPG standpoint.

The main problem with the cap for us has been it doesn't grow fast enough every year.  A team should be MORE than capable of maintaining the status quo if that's what all parties want.

For example, the KW/MOS/Buck/Hall years were the pinnacle and everyone was happy.  Until they needed a raise for everyone because everyone was performing.  First they shed Hall for cheaper Younger.  Then they shed Buck for cheaper Hogan.  Buck especially would have been perfectly happy remaining OC if he got a $50-$100k bump every year.  The fact the money for everyone simply didn't exist within the cap is what forced his move.

The fact that Mafia was built from whole cloth from relative nobodies makes it even more relevant.  It's not like we bought our way into top overpaid coaches -- we built it from almost nothing!  If you can't maintain a group like that because the cap is too constraining then something is terribly wrong with the cap!

Maybe the cap should reward team loyalty/longevity by giving cap "discounts" for every year the coach is with the team.  That would allow teams with long term groups to pay these guys what they are worth within the too-low cap.

The other main negative of the cap is it must really be hurting the guys at the low end.  I bet every team has the lower positions kept to an absolute minimum numerically so that the top dogs can take even more of the pie.  Instead we should be welcoming gobs of younger unit coaches and assistants!  How else are you going to find the next MOS.  Not to mention, the HC and main coords jobs are too harried right now because they can't delegate enough of the work.
Never go full Johnston!

Jesse

Meh, you're all trying to find work arounds for something the league doesn't have a problem with.

If goal is to spend less money, they don't care about finding a way to let teams spend more money.
My wife is amazing!

Blue In BC

Quote from: Throw Long Bannatyne on November 16, 2026, 11:26:24 PMNow the CFLPA is talking about fully guaranteed contracts, I don't know if this is supposed to be for specific players or for all, but it seems like a dangerous financial path to explore.

The Canadian Football League Players' Association (CFLPA) planted its flag on a key issue during Grey Cup week in Calgary: fully guaranteed contracts.

In their press conference on Friday, executive director David Mackie and president Solomon Elimimian indicated they want members to be eligible to sign fully guaranteed contracts, something that has never been previously available to CFL players.

"Guaranteed contracts would help provide greater stability for our members, while helping build roster continuity," said Mackie. "We want to see more of these guaranteed contracts, which will lead to more engagement with the community, build relationships with fans, fewer blank jerseys on game day, and become part of the cities and provinces that they represent."

https://3downnation.com/2026/11/13/cflpa-wants-fully-guaranteed-contracts/

A couple of things. Many veterans sign 1 year deals and vet cut down date means contracts are virtually guaranteed anyway.

The players have the NFL option clause which means they want to guarantee something they don't reciprocate. You can't have it both ways. What are they willing to give up?

It's a bad idea. Teams would be unable to release any player that made the roster. How would it impact a player being pushed back to the PR?
Time for a new start

Sir Blue and Gold

#10
It's pretty simple, coaches are either going to have some success informally negotiating pay increases commiserate with the increase in league profitability through the CEOs/owners, approved at annual meeting time and rolled out across the league, or they'll unionize themselves and show up at the league's doorstep. They'd probably prefer the former, but if they can't get enough leverage I'm sure they'll begrudgingly settle on the latter.

theaardvark

The key is flexibility.

The present system is totally inflexible, and does not allow a team to make its own decision about whether paying out a coach and making a change will cost them money short term, but lead to a better future earning.

The present system does not allow that *option*.  A team is stuck with what they have, and have to ride out the term of those contracts, with the possibility of long term harm to the franchise, fanbase and revenue stream.

By moving to a current staff cap, no team can blow up the budget on a coaching staff, but has the option of making the business decision whether to move on, or stick with what they have.

No one would be forced to spend extra, there would be no buying a top staff by overspending the cap, there would just be the ability to change horses midstream with only a financial hit that the change might more than pay for.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.

theaardvark

Guaranteeing player contracts would be a disaster.  For both teams and players.

I would think you'd see a huge shift to performance bonus based deals, making it much harder to attract players.

Only solid veterans would get any kind of decent deals, and any team could end up paying a bunch of players not to play.  Once a player sees the writing on the wall about his future, what incentive is there for him to play? DD$4 showed us what a guarantee means to some players.

Sorry, but as much as the current system favours the teams in being able to control their roster through taking advantage of non guaranteed deals, it incentivizes better play and effort by the players.  And does not reward failure, which is what guaranteed deals do.

Guaranteed deals for coaches are one thing, you want that stability in your leadership.

Guaranteeing deals for players is not a good idea. 

As someone mentioned, "vet cut down day" does create a guarantee of sorts for veteran players, I'm not adverse to seeing that modified in the players favour a little.  But ELC's should never have any level of guarantee.  A first or second year player gets his NFL window, which is a huge opportunity, but other than that, ELC's are an opportunity for a player to establish himself for a career, and are a team's cost saving tool to allow them to pay veterans more.

Or, they can shift to a UFL type deal where everyone gets the same game cheque regardless star status.

They have a nice balance between UFL and NFL pay structures.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Blue In BC on Today at 12:01:07 PMA couple of things. Many veterans sign 1 year deals and vet cut down date means contracts are virtually guaranteed anyway.

The players have the NFL option clause which means they want to guarantee something they don't reciprocate. You can't have it both ways. What are they willing to give up?

It's a bad idea. Teams would be unable to release any player that made the roster. How would it impact a player being pushed back to the PR?

It's about guaranteeing the player's payment, even if sent to the PR they would receive full pay.  I don't see it as being realistic, it's more than likely a negotiation tactic.