Front Office Salary Cap

Started by theaardvark, November 16, 2026, 03:24:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Tecno

It's ironic, I bet the coaches agreed to the cap, even welcomed it, because of the guarantee pay aspect. They didn't want to get Claybrooks'd.

But then it came back to bite them on limiting pay increases for top performers. Putting our team in coach cap heck and forcing changes when no one wanted them.

Oh ya, then it also forced the new paradigm of many HCs wearing 2 or 3 hats just to earn decent money. Those guys must be stressed out of their brain and have zero family time. Probably all going to have heart attacks at 55 too.

Careful what you wish for.
Never go full Johnston!

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Tecno on November 17, 2026, 10:28:36 PMPretty sure right now of a player has a non elc contract that they get that money as long as they are with the team. Even if they move to PR.

Otherwise, what does the word contract even mean?

Any new guarantee would be against being cut, not against being relegated to PR.

I don't think the process is as simple as you think it is, before a player accepts a spot on the PR, they are in fact cut and their playing contract is voided. Unless they have a stipulation that refers to an agreed salary they will receive on the PR they get paid a standard rate. This is why the cuts are made first after TC and the PR list is created later.

In the old days a player had to clear waivers before being added to the PR and if any team wanted to acquire them, they could. I think the same contract process exists now, they just obscure the process from public view and agree not to mess with other team's PR players in transition. I wouldn't know if the CFL has updated their rules or not.

Jesse

Quote from: Tecno on November 17, 2026, 10:34:39 PMIt's ironic, I bet the coaches agreed to the cap, even welcomed it, because of the guarantee pay aspect. They didn't want to get Claybrooks'd.

But then it came back to bite them on limiting pay increases for top performers. Putting our team in coach cap heck and forcing changes when no one wanted them.

Oh ya, then it also forced the new paradigm of many HCs wearing 2 or 3 hats just to earn decent money. Those guys must be stressed out of their brain and have zero family time. Probably all going to have heart attacks at 55 too.

Careful what you wish for.

Coaching contracts were always guaranteed. No way they wanted any part of this, but clearly nothing they could do about it.
My wife is amazing!

Tecno

Quote from: Jesse on November 18, 2026, 01:31:06 AMCoaching contracts were always guaranteed. No way they wanted any part of this, but clearly nothing they could do about it.

Except the BOG would have had to approve the change, and that means the owners/Prez's were on board.  Now, if you're saying the owners/Prez's had it in for the coaches, then maybe it would make sense.  But I would think WM would be trying to make KW/MOS happy, not miserable...
Never go full Johnston!

Jesse

Quote from: Tecno on November 18, 2026, 03:02:09 AMExcept the BOG would have had to approve the change, and that means the owners/Prez's were on board.  Now, if you're saying the owners/Prez's had it in for the coaches, then maybe it would make sense.  But I would think WM would be trying to make KW/MOS happy, not miserable...


Of course they we're on board. It means they are spending less money and more likely to get ownerships groups for BC, Montreal, Edmonton, and potential 10th team.

There were teams paying 3 head coaches at the same time when this came down. The coaches probably hate it. Fans hate it. The league and owners love it. It's doing exactly what it was supposed to.
My wife is amazing!

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Jesse on November 18, 2026, 04:44:38 PMOf course they we're on board. It means they are spending less money and more likely to get ownerships groups for BC, Montreal, Edmonton, and potential 10th team.

There were teams paying 3 head coaches at the same time when this came down. The coaches probably hate it. Fans hate it. The league and owners love it. It's doing exactly what it was supposed to.

I could be wrong but I thought the coaching cap came in after Chris Jones hired way more asst. coaches than any other team when he was in control of the Riders? 

At the time there was complaining from MLSE about how some teams had an unfair advantage because they built a fanbase that cared enough to follow their team, buy merch and attend games.

Jesse

Quote from: Throw Long Bannatyne on November 18, 2026, 05:26:37 PMI could be wrong but I thought the coaching cap came in after Chris Jones hired way more asst. coaches than any other team when he was in control of the Riders? 

At the time there was complaining from MLSE about how some teams had an unfair advantage because they built a fanbase that cared enough to follow their team, buy merch and attend games.

That's what fans blamed it on and I'm sure it was part of it - but the reason was to cut down costs. Whether you're hiring too many coaches or firing them every year and paying out multiple coaching staffs at a time.
My wife is amazing!

Pitbull

I believe the Front office salary cap has been a good thing for keeping the game coached by alumni.

Every team has most of their coaching staff being former players. There's something genuine about that.

Jesse

Quote from: Pitbull on Today at 12:20:00 AMI believe the Front office salary cap has been a good thing for keeping the game coached by alumni.

Every team has most of their coaching staff being former players. There's something genuine about that.

Yes and no.

I've heard people talk about how it leads to a lack of innovation in the CFL, just recycled people repeating the same concepts over and over.
My wife is amazing!

Tecno

Quote from: Jesse on Today at 12:26:46 AMI've heard people talk about how it leads to a lack of innovation in the CFL, just recycled people repeating the same concepts over and over.

Yup, every time there's a HC job up people start mentioning Khari, Austin, Trestman, and <insert-X-from-8-years-ago-here>.

So hard for new coaches to get their foot in the door even at the lowest end.  I guess that's why the CFL has that player->coach dev path / cheatcode now.  They saw how the cap and limitations on staff count causes stagnation.
Never go full Johnston!

Jesse

Quote from: Tecno on Today at 02:12:29 AMYup, every time there's a HC job up people start mentioning Khari, Austin, Trestman, and <insert-X-from-8-years-ago-here>.

So hard for new coaches to get their foot in the door even at the lowest end.  I guess that's why the CFL has that player->coach dev path / cheatcode now.  They saw how the cap and limitations on staff count causes stagnation.


I'm referring to player to coach causing stagnation.

Players learn concepts, become coaches, coach same concepts, repeat.
My wife is amazing!

Tecno

Quote from: Jesse on Today at 02:14:47 AMI'm referring to player to coach causing stagnation.

Players learn concepts, become coaches, coach same concepts, repeat.

Ya, I can see that. However, do you really want a guy with zero years playing ball coaching and play calling? How many guys like that exist in the CFL? Did Condell ever play?

I guess the best we can hope for is players having their own new thoughts about what is wrong and their novel, in their heads at least, ideas to solve them.

If everything is just a rehash, explain younger's crazy schemes!
Never go full Johnston!

Pitbull

Quote from: Jesse on Today at 02:14:47 AMI'm referring to player to coach causing stagnation.

Players learn concepts, become coaches, coach same concepts, repeat.

These players don't live here year round. They have their college/NFL circle and learned things they think could give them an edge. I believe from a fans standpoint, if you liked those coaches that used to be players, maybe you'll watch their games even though its not your team.

I'm thinking O'Shea has something soon and we won't have that extra 2 years to pay.

Jesse

Quote from: Pitbull on Today at 02:50:03 PMI'm thinking O'Shea has something soon and we won't have that extra 2 years to pay.

Well, there's no other vacancies at the moment for him to even be a candidate for.

I'm also unsure of the rules behind who pays him if he gets another gig.
My wife is amazing!

Throw Long Bannatyne

#29
Quote from: Jesse on Today at 02:14:47 AMI'm referring to player to coach causing stagnation.

Players learn concepts, become coaches, coach same concepts, repeat.

What stagnation? Young coaches on many teams appear to be leading the way forward.  The door is open for American coaches with no CFL experience to come in at the entry level and work their way up, but hiring one as a HC or coordinator without the background knowledge is unlikely to succeed.  At least former players understand the rules and the language being spoken.