Roster

Started by Blue In BC, November 08, 2026, 02:08:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Blue In BC on November 18, 2026, 05:17:04 PMWe moved some PR players to 1 game IR during EDF week, so that's only partially true.

Eh details, none of it matters now, one big list.

Blue In BC

Quote from: Throw Long Bannatyne on November 18, 2026, 05:31:13 PMEh details, none of it matters now, one big list.

The comment wasn't about the list per se. It was about whether we added back players that were on the PR.
Time for a new start

Tecno

If Broxton prefers RT then let him stay there. I would say you play him where he plays best, and maybe that's now RT.

However, we also have to consider what our options are for LT. We can't start someone substandard at either spot.

There's precedent for RT being higher paid than LT... Ssk for all the Yoshi years.

If they are putting out rumors of ankles to protect Stan, and now Broxton wants RT... we may be looking at a return of Stan and Neufeld... And Zach??
Never go full Johnston!

Jesse

Quote from: Tecno on November 18, 2026, 06:11:44 PMIf Broxton prefers RT then let him stay there. I would say you play him where he plays best, and maybe that's now RT.

However, we also have to consider what our options are for LT. We can't start someone substandard at either spot.

There's precedent for RT being higher paid than LT... Ssk for all the Yoshi years.

If they are putting out rumors of ankles to protect Stan, and now Broxton wants RT... we may be looking at a return of Stan and Neufeld... And Zach??

It's the most likely scenario.
My wife is amazing!

Waffler

Ankle shmankle. I recall him getting beat even in training camp like I'd never seen before. Not often but when he did you noticed.

He's 40. He gets hurt easier and heals slower. To me it's one more reason to call it a career. It can only get worse from here.
"Don't cry and don't rage. Understand." ― Spinoza
__________________________________________________
Everything seems stupid when it fails.  - Fyodor Dostoevsky

Throw Long Bannatyne

#95
Quote from: Tecno on November 18, 2026, 06:11:44 PMIf Broxton prefers RT then let him stay there. I would say you play him where he plays best, and maybe that's now RT.

However, we also have to consider what our options are for LT. We can't start someone substandard at either spot.

There's precedent for RT being higher paid than LT... Ssk for all the Yoshi years.

If they are putting out rumors of ankles to protect Stan, and now Broxton wants RT... we may be looking at a return of Stan and Neufeld... And Zach??

LT's have historically been paid the highest because they protect the QB's blindside, as we've seen with Zach he doesn't react well to a rusher coming from his backside whereas he can usually see and dodge rushers coming from his right. 

Think of Lemon, every time he injured a QB he was coming through on the blindside of a QB standing in the pocket, he's not capable of  chasing down if they're already in motion running away from him.

Blue In BC

#96
Quote from: Tecno on November 18, 2026, 06:11:44 PMIf Broxton prefers RT then let him stay there. I would say you play him where he plays best, and maybe that's now RT.

However, we also have to consider what our options are for LT. We can't start someone substandard at either spot.

There's precedent for RT being higher paid than LT... Ssk for all the Yoshi years.

If they are putting out rumors of ankles to protect Stan, and now Broxton wants RT... we may be looking at a return of Stan and Neufeld... And Zach??

I don't agree. Like I said he had become the best or near best LT in the league. It's a more critical position than RT for a right handed QB. The fact RT is an easier spot physically and mentally for him is somewhat irrelevant.

It's good that he has that skill now as well, but I want to see him at LT in 2027.

You can't compare that to the Rider situation. They didn't have one of the best LT's when they added Hardrick to their roster.
Time for a new start

Jesse

Quote from: Blue In BC on November 18, 2026, 08:32:28 PMI don't agree. Like I said he had become the best or near best LT in the league. It's a more critical position than RT for a right handed QB. The fact RT is an easier spot physically and mentally for him is somewhat irrelevant.

It's good that he has that skill now as well, but I want to see him at LT in 2027.

You can't compare that to the Rider situation. They didn't have one of the best LT's when they added Hardrick to their roster.

Tackles are equally important. The blindside does nothing to increase or decrease their value.
My wife is amazing!

Blue In BC

Quote from: Jesse on November 18, 2026, 09:10:00 PMTackles are equally important. The blindside does nothing to increase or decrease their value.

That's not true and that's why they call it the blindside. LT's have historically been paid more whether import or Canadian.  It's true in all football leagues.

Now if the QB is a lefty than the RT is the blindside but the number of left handed QB's is less than right handed.
Time for a new start

dd

Quote from: Blue In BC on November 18, 2026, 09:20:19 PMThat's not true and that's why they call it the blindside. LT's have historically been paid more whether import or Canadian.  It's true in all football leagues.

Now if the QB is a lefty than the RT is the blindside but the number of left handed QB's is less than right handed.
Exactly. LT is THE most important position on the OL protection wise and if we want to keep our Qb healthy and off the IR, we'd move league most outstanding OL Broxton to LT, not questions asked, and the slower aging Bryant can go to RT or retire. I am tired of the excuses at LT, ankle injury is a smoke screen, he slower than a sloth and beat regularly and gave up a league high 9 sacks and god knows how many hits on the Qb. Enough already, move on and put the all star in there.

Jesse

Quote from: Blue In BC on November 18, 2026, 09:20:19 PMThat's not true and that's why they call it the blindside. LT's have historically been paid more whether import or Canadian.  It's true in all football leagues.

Now if the QB is a lefty than the RT is the blindside but the number of left handed QB's is less than right handed.

It's an old philosophy that doesn't actually hold any merit. Top left and right tackles are paid equally in the NFL.
My wife is amazing!