Toronto@ Winnipeg Pre-game

Started by Pigskin, September 20, 2026, 01:48:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

BBRT

Quote from: Throw Long Bannatyne on September 23, 2026, 09:28:29 PMFrom the horse's mouth, Zach will not play this weekend.

Maybe it is time to put Zach on the 6 game injury list - then when the season wraps thank him for his years of dedication and tell him it is time for him to retire for his own good.

Blue In BC

#61
I think this is the end for Collaros. Even if he can return before the end of the season IMO he should be moved to # 2 QB at best.

Not playing this week is a vague bit of information as to whether they even expect he can / should return at some point.

Take the SMS savings, try and get some live reps for Elgersma and move on.

Zach has a degenerative issue and can't take the least hit behind an OL that can't protect well.

Thanks for the time in Winnipeg but it's family time now.
One game at a time

Blue In BC

#62
Griffin not coming back this week but this was only week 5 of his 6 game IR so that was expected.

Dixon listed as available and he just completed his 6 game IR stint. So he might move to AR bumping someone.
One game at a time

Sir Blue and Gold

Quote from: BBRT on September 23, 2026, 09:34:59 PMMaybe it is time to put Zach on the 6 game injury list - then when the season wraps thank him for his years of dedication and tell him it is time for him to retire for his own good.

Hopefully. He's just not good enough anymore. Sorry.

theaardvark

Quote from: bomb squad on September 23, 2026, 06:03:23 PMIf he was as good as Collaros, he would be the starter. It's that simple. He hasn't shown yet that he is, so he's not.

I didn't say Dru was better, I said current Zach isn't much better than Dru.

And yes, if Dru was marginally better than Zach, Zach would play.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.

Blueforlife

#65
Quote from: theaardvark on September 23, 2026, 11:50:11 PMI didn't say Dru was better, I said current Zach isn't much better than Dru.

And yes, if Dru was marginally better than Zach, Zach would play.

I am not buying this. Back tracking here a little imo.

Jesse

We've said this over and over this year, but it is seemingly not in Zach's best interest to be playing football at this point. The most innocuous hits take him out for weeks and it just feels irresponsible of the franchise to keep trotting him out there.

That said, I completely expect to see him back as soon as he's "cleared".
My wife is amazing!

dd

Quote from: Blue In BC on September 23, 2026, 09:39:51 PMI think this is the end for Collaros. Even if he can return before the end of the season IMO he should be moved to # 2 QB at best.

Not playing this week is a vague bit of information as to whether they even expect he can / should return at some point.

Take the SMS savings, try and get some liver reps for Elgersma and move on.

Zach has a degenerative issue and can't take the least hit behind an OL that can't protect well.

Thanks for the time in Winnipeg but it's family time now.
Would you guys forget Elgersma right now, I just don't get the love affair with this guy,  if anyone is getting reps, its Brown...we need to win games to get into the playoffs, with Brown we have a shot, with Elgersma, not a hope in hell. enough already.

Blueforlife

#68
This is Zach's swan song, let him take one more crack at it imo

It's a fine line though

I think with Brown its a coin flip at best to make or win a playoff game

With Zach 60 to 70% imo

Brown will be better next year I think

Friday will be very telling.  He needs to push the ball down field or we are cooked.

bomb squad

Quote from: theaardvark on September 23, 2026, 11:50:11 PMI didn't say Dru was better, I said current Zach isn't much better than Dru.

And yes, if Dru was marginally better than Zach, Zach would play.

I was neither agreeing or disagreeing with what you said. I was adding my own view on the comparison between the two.

Blue In BC

#70
Quote from: dd on Today at 01:03:15 AMWould you guys forget Elgersma right now, I just don't get the love affair with this guy,  if anyone is getting reps, its Brown...we need to win games to get into the playoffs, with Brown we have a shot, with Elgersma, not a hope in hell. enough already.

I have no particular interest in Elgersma beyond evaluating him if we have an opportunity. Our season is hanging by a thread. If we end up eliminated then put him into a game.

For that matter I wouldn't be opposed to seeing Perkins get a few reps if a game situation allows.

Our chances to hang onto a playoff spot starts tomorrow. Winning and hopefully the Stamps lose would help. We have the more difficult schedule.

One game at a time