We need a backup quarterback!

Started by Austin85, September 02, 2024, 04:14:41 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

bwiser

Quote from: BlueInCgy on September 08, 2024, 08:44:21 PMPut Augustine in for short yardage plunge.
I noticed BC was using their fullback in short yardage situations. Might not be a bad idea.

Pigskin

Quote from: BlueInCgy on September 08, 2024, 08:44:21 PMPut Augustine in for short yardage plunge.

Big difference between Mackie and JA27. Mackie 6'2" 252. JA27 5'9" 200.
Don't go through life looking in the rearview mirror.

ModAdmin

I would think, assuming CS17 is out for a period of time and barring a trade, we will need to bring in a third QB during the bye week.  Riding with only 2  seems dangerous.
"You can't let praise or criticism get to you. It's a weakness to get caught up in either one." - John Wooden

M.O.A.B.

Im ok with Dolegala as short-yardage QB.

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: M.O.A.B. on September 09, 2024, 12:16:59 AMIm ok with Dolegala as short-yardage QB.

I'd nix that move, don't even think the Riders used him in that capacity, he's too tall.  Corny wasn't great at it, but occasionally he could break outside and outrun all the little people.

TecnoGenius

Quote from: Waffler on September 08, 2024, 02:45:21 PMHe'd be a rental but I am sure he would finish this season here with the chance to get one more ring.

BLM isn't interested in getting a ring as #2, it'll hurt his feewings and tarnish his precious legacy.  He might do it if Zach got a season-ender, though.  If we were that desperate, sure, I'd swallow my pride and take him.
Never go full Rider!

Bluehawk

Quote from: Blueforlife on September 08, 2024, 05:22:38 PMI didn't know that thanks.

So far the list of possible replacements (I am making a list and keeping up to date from folks suggestions):

Jake D.
Pipkin
Fine
Taylor Cornelius

Long shot
BLM

Maybe?
Matthew Shiltz
Chase Brice (was with BC)
NFL cut, neg. list, US college guy
Prukop

Let's keep the list going fellas


Quote from: Blueforlife on September 08, 2024, 05:22:38 PMI didn't know that thanks.

So far the list of possible replacements (I am making a list and keeping up to date from folks suggestions):

Jake D.
Pipkin
Fine
Taylor Cornelius

Long shot
BLM

Maybe?
Matthew Shiltz
Chase Brice (was with BC)
NFL cut, neg. list, US college guy
Prukop

Let's keep the list going fellas


With Strev very possibly done for the season, Bombers will need a go to second stringer with experience in the league.  My vote would be for Taylor Cornelius as he has had the best success from those listed so far.
I'd rather be a Bomber than a .....

TecnoGenius

CRITICAL: Strev is 2 QBs in one:

A. he's a legit .500 #1 if Zach gets hurt
B. he's a pretty good SY QB

Losing Strev means we just lost both.  There is no other QB in the league that is as good at both that is unsigned or likely available (trade).

So that means anyone we will get only be one of A or B!  So it is critical to identify what it is we need more.

The question is then: can Wilson do SY (B) well.  We all know Wilson will not be a good injury-backup (A) right now (odds of that are maybe 10% because he's a rookie).  From what I saw, Wilson looks ready to be good at SY.  So let's say (B) is covered.

So that leaves (A): a legit #2 in case Zach goes down.  We should 100% focus on this.  So cross all the "SY specialists" and "turf-throwers" off the "maybe" list (so no Prukop-type guy).

With so few games left, we should be able to afford anyone we can find.  And there's enough time before the post-season to get them up to speed.  If we don't think we have the money, or no one is available (trade or couch) then we could roll with another rookie, but that's a huuuuge gamble and who's to say he'll be better than Wilson.

Out of the names mentioned, the only guys that fit this bill that have a hope in heck of being available (by any means) are: Powell, Schiltz, BLM, Masoli, Ford.  Weaker options are: Corny, Pipkin.  Everyone else is just SY or hot garbage and I'd rather run with Wilson as #2.

I would jump all over Powell as he was looking great this season and would be affordable in terms of trade-bait.  That would assume he's not HAM's "future", of course.  Masoli/BLM/Ford would take a miracle to get a trade arranged, but I list for completeness as there is a chance they aren't part of their teams' 2025 plans.
Never go full Rider!

peg_city


LXTSN

I would like to see either Cornelius or Pigrome. To me it's gotta be a free agent and someone who can run!

Pigrome failed on his QB sneak opportunity here, but was a wrecking ball when asked to run the ball out of shotgun.

Cornelius was great at short yardage, and I think he would win about the same amount of games as Streveler would starting at QB.

Blueforlife

#175
Quote from: TecnoGenius on September 09, 2024, 08:48:02 AMCRITICAL: Strev is 2 QBs in one:

A. he's a legit .500 #1 if Zach gets hurt
B. he's a pretty good SY QB

Losing Strev means we just lost both.  There is no other QB in the league that is as good at both that is unsigned or likely available (trade).

So that means anyone we will get only be one of A or B!  So it is critical to identify what it is we need more.

The question is then: can Wilson do SY (B) well.  We all know Wilson will not be a good injury-backup (A) right now (odds of that are maybe 10% because he's a rookie).  From what I saw, Wilson looks ready to be good at SY.  So let's say (B) is covered.

So that leaves (A): a legit #2 in case Zach goes down.  We should 100% focus on this.  So cross all the "SY specialists" and "turf-throwers" off the "maybe" list (so no Prukop-type guy).

With so few games left, we should be able to afford anyone we can find.  And there's enough time before the post-season to get them up to speed.  If we don't think we have the money, or no one is available (trade or couch) then we could roll with another rookie, but that's a huuuuge gamble and who's to say he'll be better than Wilson.

Out of the names mentioned, the only guys that fit this bill that have a hope in heck of being available (by any means) are: Powell, Schiltz, BLM, Masoli, Ford.  Weaker options are: Corny, Pipkin.  Everyone else is just SY or hot garbage and I'd rather run with Wilson as #2.

I would jump all over Powell as he was looking great this season and would be affordable in terms of trade-bait.  That would assume he's not HAM's "future", of course.  Masoli/BLM/Ford would take a miracle to get a trade arranged, but I list for completeness as there is a chance they aren't part of their teams' 2025 plans.
Some interesting points here.  We have to be realistic about who we could get imo.

Ridermania

I'd expect a new QB to be signed this week.

blue_gold_84

#forthew
лава Україні!
Elbows up!
井の中の蛙大海を知らず
History doesn't repeat itself, but it often rhymes.
In a world of human wreckage.

J5V

Quote from: TecnoGenius on September 09, 2024, 08:26:48 AMBLM isn't interested in getting a ring as #2, it'll hurt his feewings and tarnish his precious legacy.  He might do it if Zach got a season-ender, though.  If we were that desperate, sure, I'd swallow my pride and take him.
Agreed. It would have a certain odour to it, but a cup is a cup
Go Bombers!

peg_city

Quote from: blue_gold_84 on September 09, 2024, 04:33:37 PMIn Winnipeg? Never.

A couple of more losses and Calgary is out of it.

Wilson could be our short yardage QB. Maier is our back-up.

Unless BLM is available, Maier might be the best option.