Ricky Walker

[Blue In BC]

I debated the pros and cons of players all the time.  I have debated coaches decisions and roster moves.   I have been a big supporter of this group for many years but I am never shy to voice my opinion or criticism.  I don't live in a world where everything is sunshine and roses; I simply state my opinion on the players, coaches and management on here as it relates to the CFL.

We all have a role to play here and I value yours.  Our realities are based on our own views and we are all here to present and debate everything CFL.

I recall you mentioned that we had ten LBs in another post and figured that meant you were thinking we were dressing too many.  I thought your position was to dress a DL over Jackson.  I am sorry if I made incorrect assumptions.

I don't appreciate you making strong statements above that don't fully illustrate my role or how I post on here.  Yes I'm positive but I provide more than just that imo.  There is  small group on here that likes to go to the PJ is only positive argument when we get in a debate.  That stick gets old fast.  Let's focus on the ball club please.

There are some that share you view on Jackson taking a roster spot and some that are happy with management's decision on that.  This debate will continue.

The problem is that you seem to be in the minority more often. Nothing wrong with being patient with a players development but that can be carried too far too soon. I suppose nothing really wrong with being in the minority a few times.

You might note your conversations in this string with Modadmin as an example.

I think you got confused about my LB views when I have targeted Briggs. It's not that he's a LB but he's really digressed in his play. Is there a better choice from our PR, possibly not. Only two 2023 draft choices and neither fit that particular bill. O'Shea said Briggs is a good leader and I don't doubt that. I also don't doubt for a second that he is a defensive liability.

Combining all those comments, if Clements was healthy he would be that extra asset on defence over Jackson or Briggs. Obviously there is a ratio aspect but I would then suggest Kelly might be added as an overall ratio replacement. He plays on ST's and live reps would beneficial.

[pjrocksmb]

The problem is that you seem to be in the minority more often. Nothing wrong with being patient with a players development but that can be carried too far too soon. I suppose nothing really wrong with being in the minority a few times.

You might note your conversations in this string with Modadmin as an example.  I think I have a pretty good track record of being right or close to it on patience with players, coaches and management.  Was sure the target years ago before we starting winning and got our cups.  My take on the Bombers has been very positive and consistent for many years.  Maybe I'm too high on Briggs but within his role I have really liked him and prefer consistency with our role players.  Doesn't surprise me he is a leader, just like with hockey so player are the glue in the room.

I think you got confused about my LB views when I have targeted Briggs. It's not that he's a LB but he's really digressed in his play. Is there a better choice from our PR, possibly not. Only two 2023 draft choices and neither fit that particular bill. O'Shea said Briggs is a good leader and I don't doubt that. I also don't doubt for a second that he is a defensive liability.

Combining all those comments, if Clements was healthy he would be that extra asset on defence over Jackson or Briggs. Obviously there is a ratio aspect but I would then suggest Kelly might be added as an overall ratio replacement. He plays on ST's and live reps would beneficial.

I rarely move with the herd and that at times makes me a target for arguments.  I did get mixed up with our LB Briggs chat and this one lol.

I would take Briggs over Clements but that's a tough one.  I do like Clements too and with more reps his ceiling is high.  Briggs is a steady know commodity, reached his ceiling early in his career.  I don't see Briggs as a liability but we have gone over that before.  I would take Clements over Jackson buy again close call.  Kelly I don't know enough about can you remind me?  Yup ratio is king.  Often these are not one to one options for roster spots.  Each week lots of moving parts.  I think we have benefited greatly from little changes to the roster week to week.  Wasn't that long ago some wanted changes on the OL, that crowd got quiet lol.

Modadmin and I rarely agree on much.  How she goes.  Doesn't mean either of us are right or wrong just seam to be Ying and yang with my views vs. some.  That's the strength of this place.  Everyone has their view points and way of interacting with others. 

I can be like sand paper sometimes mostly because I have an opinion / comment / counter on just about anything.  Depends on my mood.  My mental health is  not as steady as most peoples.  Have my ups and downs.  I also like a good debate and enjoy the back and forth battle.

[Blue In BC]

I rarely move with the herd and that at times makes me a target for arguments.  I did get mixed up with our LB Briggs chat and this one lol.

I would take Briggs over Clements but that's a tough one.  I do like Clements too and with more reps his ceiling is high.  Briggs is a steady know commodity, reached his ceiling early in his career.  I don't see Briggs as a liability but we have gone over that before.  I would take Clements over Jackson buy again close call.  Kelly I don't know enough about can you remind me?  Yup ratio is king.  Often these are not one to one options for roster spots.  Each week lots of moving parts.  I think we have benefited greatly from little changes to the roster week to week.  Wasn't that long ago some wanted changes on the OL, that crowd got quiet lol.

Modadmin and I rarely agree on much.  How she goes.  Doesn't mean either of us are right or wrong just seam to be Ying and yang with my views vs. some.  That's the strength of this place.  Everyone has their view points and way of interacting with others. 

I can be like sand paper sometimes mostly because I have an opinion / comment / counter on just about anything.  Depends on my mood.  My mental health is  not as steady as most peoples.  Have my ups and downs.  I also like a good debate and enjoy the back and forth battle.

Briggs has the leadership advantage over Clement and the ratio aspect as well. With so few DI's it's not a direct choice between those two as an example.

I would suggest you watch Briggs and even Clement more closely to see who is in " chase mode " more often.

Kelly was the DB we picked at 15 in the 2023 draft.  He looked quick and played well on ST's in pre season. Another raw talent. There isn't really a need for another DB on the roster per se and there will be even less if Ford returns.

So depending on when and if we make some of those other changes, then Kelly might might get another look on the AR.  Roster shuffling is a domino effect and not always a direct replacement. So we agree on that point.

Just thinking out loud that a young faster player on ST's like Kelly might be an asset over someone like Briggs. If Clement is better than Briggs at LB it would off set 1 LB for 1 LB but also impacts ratio, hence domino.

Just checked 2022 stats and Ford had 10 ST's in 13 games. So that means I did have that impression of him being very good on ST's.

[Pigskin]

Clements was having a pretty good season before he was injured. I thinking he would replace, Cole when he gets back.

[ModAdmin]

My final thought on PJ. You continually - in multiple threads - tell people they are wrong and to focus on the subject, not you. By doing that you are inviting people to do just that - focus on you. Perhaps keep your references to yourself out of it as well as dismissing other's views with a word you frequently like to use - "Nah". I honestly believe addressing those issues would help you and the forum.

Now back to Ricky Walker.  

[Blue In BC]

Clements was having a pretty good season before he was injured. I thinking he would replace, Cole when he gets back.

Clement is a better defensive player at the moment. Cole has been better on ST's as far as I can tell. I do think Cole might have more upside but that won't necessarily keep him on the AR.

IIRC, Clement had an ankle injury so he could practice this week if healthy and be an option to return for game 13?

[DM83]

Hey PJ ,

Keep on rocking.
Having varied opinions makes us all stronger.

The players we are discussing, are all very good.
These Guys are all amazing athletes.

The guys that play pro football are extraordinary.
At this level, when given the chance they HAVE to make the play. 
And don?t forget, the guys they play against are getting paid.

On our top teams the players are guys who make their play the greater number of times.

Fun, fun, fun.