Mike O’Shea Fired

Started by Jesse, November 19, 2026, 12:36:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

dd

Well I for one am not a fan of the decision. We be had incredible success during mos tenure, and you can't go 14-4 and win the grey cup every year, you can try to but injuries happen, star players get poached by higher bidding clubs you steadily lose the talent you recruited so of course your going to decline. We lost allstars ty ford, Kenny lawler and Liam Dobson and replaced them with plumbers, that's not on mos, that's on our scouts and GM.  MOS created a clubhouse most free agents sought to be a part of and our club played hard, **** hard for mos, fought to the bitter end in every game. Good luck getting a clubhouse that will do that moving forward. Also good luck resigning our free agents with a new head coach coming in, it ain't gonna happen. They are going to go to clubs with stablility not one in massive transition. We are now going back to the reinbold era where a record of 9-9 will be a dream, we re about to become the Ottawa redblacks of the west. The free spot on the bingo card. Well done miller!!

theaardvark

Quote from: dd on Today at 07:53:14 PMWell I for one am not a fan of the decision. We be had incredible success during mos tenure, and you can't go 14-4 and win the grey cup every year, you can try to but injuries happen, star players get poached by higher bidding clubs you steadily lose the talent you recruited so of course your going to decline. We lost allstars ty ford, Kenny lawler and Liam Dobson and replaced them with plumbers, that's not on mos, that's on our scouts and GM.  MOS created a clubhouse most free agents sought to be a part of and our club played hard, **** hard for mos, fought to the bitter end in every game. Good luck getting a clubhouse that will do that moving forward. Also good luck resigning our free agents with a new head coach coming in, it ain't gonna happen. They are going to go to clubs with stablility not one in massive transition. We are now going back to the reinbold era where a record of 9-9 will be a dream, we re about to become the Ottawa redblacks of the west. The free spot on the bingo card. Well done miller!!

Even the best coaches wear thin.  Look at Maurice.  Moved forward with the Jets until he didn't, change of scenes and both Jets and Maurice doing much better.

MOS isn't a bad coach, he is one of the best.  But he's worn thin, and I think fans are tired of his "we got to go out and with each game" kumbaya attitude.  I wanted to see a little fire, not a Maas level inferno, but just get PO'd now and then.  Not sure that the players coming up and stuck behind guys that were underperforming weren't mad as well. 

The killer for me was Singer.  So many said he showed well in pre-season, but he never even got a sniff until injury made an opening.

I always loved the "Drumline" idea, being able to challenge the guy ahead of you for that spot.  Hard to do in football, but still, the idea that you can move up based on play in practice needs more opportunity.
Unabashed positron.  Blue koolaid in my fridge.  I wear my blue sunglasses at night.  Homer, d'oh.

Pete

Quote from: dd on Today at 07:53:14 PMWell I for one am not a fan of the decision. We be had incredible success during mos tenure, and you can't go 14-4 and win the grey cup every year, you can try to but injuries happen, star players get poached by higher bidding clubs you steadily lose the talent you recruited so of course your going to decline. We lost allstars ty ford, Kenny lawler and Liam Dobson and replaced them with plumbers, that's not on mos, that's on our scouts and GM.  MOS created a clubhouse most free agents sought to be a part of and our club played hard, **** hard for mos, fought to the bitter end in every game. Good luck getting a clubhouse that will do that moving forward. Also good luck resigning our free agents with a new head coach coming in, it ain't gonna happen. They are going to go to clubs with stablility not one in massive transition. We are now going back to the reinbold era where a record of 9-9 will be a dream, we re about to become the Ottawa redblacks of the west. The free spot on the bingo card. Well done miller!!
A lot of your concerns will be affected by who we bring in. New coaches didnt have much of a negative effect on teams like Edmonton and Saskatchewan. I expect '27 to be a rebuilding year  but with the new playoff format who knows what we can do come playoff time.
  For example if we were able to bring back Buck Pierce, how would that impact your scenarios. Some guys i would like to see interviewed include
Pierce
Sherritt
Calvillo
Id stay away from Dinwiddie and Thorpe.

Sway

I guess I'm old enough to remember Buck's pathetic Grey Cup game plans

I don't understand this campaign to bring him back.

Typical Winnipeg, "oh his wife lives here and he lives in a camper in BC so it works"

He still never had to even answer for the 24 GC play calling

Oshea protected him and he took off to BC with out a peep as to why Terry Wilson is throwing his first pass on his first ever play ever , in a GC.

Buck is basically Oshea,  no fire, slow, no intensity.

With out Rourke BC would have fired him already

Sure he's better than Jarious Jackson or Bob Dyce,  but. We can do better.

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: theaardvark on Today at 08:03:19 PMEven the best coaches wear thin.  Look at Maurice.  Moved forward with the Jets until he didn't, change of scenes and both Jets and Maurice doing much better.

MOS isn't a bad coach, he is one of the best.  But he's worn thin, and I think fans are tired of his "we got to go out and with each game" kumbaya attitude.  I wanted to see a little fire, not a Maas level inferno, but just get PO'd now and then.  Not sure that the players coming up and stuck behind guys that were underperforming weren't mad as well. 

The killer for me was Singer.  So many said he showed well in pre-season, but he never even got a sniff until injury made an opening.

I always loved the "Drumline" idea, being able to challenge the guy ahead of you for that spot.  Hard to do in football, but still, the idea that you can move up based on play in practice needs more opportunity.

Flash back to the last Chris Jones era in Edmonton prior to Ed Hervey.  There was little continuity of personale, every game was a different combo playing together for the first time, often with 3 new faces per game. He showed over and over he was a good defensive coach but when you shuffle the player deck and choose raw talent over knowledge and experience, chemistry never forms and a good team doesn't emerge from the chaos.

Throw Long Bannatyne

Quote from: Sway on Today at 08:22:39 PMI guess I'm old enough to remember Buck's pathetic Grey Cup game plans

I don't understand this campaign to bring him back.

Typical Winnipeg, "oh his wife lives here and he lives in a camper in BC so it works"

He still never had to even answer for the 24 GC play calling

Oshea protected him and he took off to BC with out a peep as to why Terry Wilson is throwing his first pass on his first ever play ever , in a GC.

Buck is basically Oshea,  no fire, slow, no intensity.

With out Rourke BC would have fired him already

Sure he's better than Jarious Jackson or Bob Dyce,  but. We can do better.


Buck has young children, that's got to be a killer to be away from them during the season, they're only young once and those are by far the best years.

Waffler

JC Sherritt (38)
Marc Mueller (37)
Jordan Maksymic (39)

I feel these are the 3 up and comers. I think this is what Miller wants. My guess is Sherritt.
"Don't cry and don't rage. Understand." ― Spinoza
__________________________________________________
Everything seems stupid when it fails.  - Fyodor Dostoevsky

TrueBlue4

JC Sherritt (38)
Marc Mueller (37)
Jordan Maksymic (39)

I feel these are the 3 up and comers. I think this is what Miller wants. My guess is Sherritt.

I would add A. Cavillo - at least kick the tires

dd

Quote from: Pete on Today at 08:07:27 PMA lot of your concerns will be affected by who we bring in. New coaches didnt have much of a negative effect on teams like Edmonton and Saskatchewan. I expect '27 to be a rebuilding year  but with the new playoff format who knows what we can do come playoff time.
  For example if we were able to bring back Buck Pierce, how would that impact your scenarios. Some guys i would like to see interviewed include
Pierce
Sherritt
Calvillo
Id stay away from Dinwiddie and Thorpe.

Hey Pete, my point was MOS coaching style didn't change, the quality of personnel he was coaching did, and that was the ultimate reason for our declining win-loss record. That's not on him, he can only coach who KW and the scouts bring in. Give him a Kenny Lawler, a Liam Dobson (please for our O line!!) and Ty Ford to lock down at corner to this years team, and our team looks drastically different and would have been reflected in our win-loss record, we would have been in the 11-7 area for sure. But no, lets fire the coach because we couldn't re-sign an all star reciever, all star NAT guard, and all star NAT corner--that's 2 NAT all stars lost and replaced by nobody's. That's not on MOS. That's what upsets me. Miller saying he wants to go in a different direction, well hey Wade, how about we sign our top stars and quit letting them go to other teams and quit trying to replace them with nobody's and then complain because our record is sliding!!! That's the direction I'd like to see us take. Do you think Montreal is going to let Philipot ever go, not a chance. He's an all star NAT, worth his weight in gold, and we let Dobson and Ford go and didn't bat an eye. And then complain we want to do in a different direction. Give me a stinking break already!!